General Contractor in Oyster Bay, NY
Historic Restoration, Renovations & Custom Millwork
Minutes from our Glen Cove office. Fully licensed and insured · (516) 759-1999
Gothic Construction is a general contractor serving Oyster Bay and the harbor villages around it: Oyster Bay Cove, Cove Neck, Centre Island, Mill Neck and Laurel Hollow. Our Glen Cove office is a short drive away. We restore and renovate homes ranging from 18th- and 19th-century houses near the downtown to waterfront homes on the harbor. Because our roots are in master carpentry and custom millwork, we can rebuild a porch, a staircase or a run of period trim in our own shop instead of searching for a near match.
Oyster Bay Homes We Work On
Oyster Bay has more recorded history than almost anywhere on Long Island. The downtown has about half of the Town of Oyster Bay's designated landmarks, from colonial-era buildings like Raynham Hall to Victorian-era storefronts and homes. On the streets around Audrey Avenue and South Street, you'll find colonials, folk Victorians and Craftsman bungalows, many with deep front porches. Toward the water and out on Cove Neck and Centre Island, the homes get larger and more exposed to the elements: shingled houses, estate properties and waterfront homes facing the harbor and the Sound.
Older houses here usually need two things at once. First, the parts the street can see have to look the way they did originally: porch columns, railings, clapboard, cornices and windows. Second, the inside needs structure, insulation and systems that can handle a modern family and a coastal winter. We plan both from the start. That avoids redoing finished work once a beam or a sill turns out to be rotted.
Our Services in Oyster Bay
Historic restoration and renovation. Porches, siding, trim, windows and structural repairs on older homes, matched to the original profiles. See our Glen Cove exterior restoration
Whole-home and gut renovations. New layouts, mechanicals and finishes, from framing through final punch list. See residential projects
Custom millwork and cabinetry. Kitchens, libraries, mantels, built-ins and staircases made by our own carpenters. See millwork
Waterfront decks and outdoor carpentry. Ipe, mahogany and composite decks and railings built for salt air and harbor wind. See decks
Additions. Primary suites, kitchens and second stories that fit the scale and style of the existing house.
Permits: Town, Village or Landmark?
Around Oyster Bay, three separate approvals can apply, and a mailing address doesn't tell you which ones do.
The hamlet of Oyster Bay is unincorporated. Building permits come from the Town of Oyster Bay Department of Planning and Development, whose Building Division is at 74 Audrey Avenue, in the hamlet itself.
Oyster Bay Cove, Cove Neck, Centre Island, Mill Neck and Laurel Hollow are incorporated villages. Each one has its own building department and its own rules. In Oyster Bay Cove, for example, some projects need site plan approval from the village Planning Board before a permit can be issued.
Town-designated landmarks need approval from the Town's Landmarks Preservation Commission for exterior changes visible from the street.
Before design starts, we confirm which offices have jurisdiction over your property and build their review time into the schedule.
What Our Clients Say
"Their attention to detail is unsurpassed. I highly recommend."
Michael G., Google review
Why Oyster Bay Homeowners Choose Gothic
Carpenters, not just coordinators. We make replacement trim, railings and millwork ourselves, so they match what's already on the house.
We read old houses before opening them. We assess framing, sills and moisture before demolition, so surprises are found early, not halfway through the job.
One point of contact for the schedule, the budget and every agency approval.
Over 100 years of combined experience in high-end construction on the North Shore and in Manhattan.
Start Your Oyster Bay Project
Send us a few photos of your home and a note about what you'd like to change. We'll schedule a walkthrough, confirm which permits and approvals your property needs, and give you a clear scope and next steps.
Schedule a site visit →
Call (516) 759-1999 · 32 D Glen St, Glen Cove, NY 11542 · Mon–Sat 9–5
